3 min read

Summary: Rick Mulready - I Tested 9 “Overhyped” AI Writing Tools... Here's the Best One

Summary: Rick Mulready - I Tested 9 “Overhyped” AI Writing Tools... Here's the Best One
For a more detailed analysis, watch Rick Mulready's full video on YouTube.

In this video, Rick Mulready reviewed nine AI writing tools to determine their effectiveness and value. His criteria included the generic nature of the writing, memory capabilities, ease of use, and cost. Below is a summary of his findings:

Evaluation Criteria

(Scored out of 20)

  1. Generic Writing: Natural vs. robotic output.
  2. Memory: Ability to build on initial prompts.
  3. Ease of Use: User interface and functionality.
  4. Cost: Affordability and value.

Tools Reviewed and Ratings:

  1. Jasper AI:
    • Generic Writing: 2
    • Memory: 2
    • Ease of Use: 4
    • Cost: 1
    • Total: 9
  2. Copy.ai:
    • Generic Writin: 4
    • Memory: 4
    • Ease of Use: 1
    • Cost: 1
    • Total: 10
  3. Grammarly:
    • Generic Writing: 2
    • Memory: 2
    • Ease of Use: 1
    • Cost: 4
    • Total: 9
  4. Writer:
    • Generic Writing: 1
    • Memory: 2
    • Ease of Use: 2
    • Cost: 5
    • Total: 10
  5. Writesonic:
    • Generic Writing: 2
    • Memory: 4
    • Ease of Use: 2
    • Cost: 5
    • Total: 13
  6. Anyword:
    • Generic Writing: 4
    • Memory: 1
    • Ease of Use: 4
    • Cost: 2
    • Total: 11
  7. Ink Editor:
    • Generic Writing: 1
    • Memory: 1
    • Ease of Use: 4
    • Cost: 1
    • Total: 7
  8. AI Writer:
    • Generic Writing: 1
    • Memory: 4
    • Ease of Use: 4
    • Cost: 5
    • Total: 11
  9. Claude 3 (Opus):
    • Generic Writing: 5
    • Memory: 5
    • Ease of Use: 4
    • Cost: 4
    • Total: 18

Winner: Claude 3 (Opus)

Rick found Claude 3 to be the best AI writing tool, scoring 18 out of 20. It excelled in generating human-like, empathetic, and relevant content. Its ease of use and reasonable cost ($20 per month) made it the top choice.


Detailed Analysis

Jasper AI

Rick revisited Jasper AI to assess its improvements. The interface is cleaner and more user-friendly compared to earlier versions. However, the content generated was still generic and lacked depth. Jasper AI's overall score was 9 out of 20, with the cost being a significant drawback at $50-$70 per month.

Copy.ai

Copy.ai has transitioned from a simple writing tool to a more comprehensive workflow and automation system. Although the interface was intuitive and the writing quality slightly better than Jasper AI, it still did not meet expectations, scoring 10 out of 20.

Grammarly

Grammarly, traditionally known for grammar checking, has ventured into generative AI. Unfortunately, its foray into this domain has not been very successful, producing limited and somewhat robotic content. The tool scored 9 out of 20, primarily due to its restricted functionality in content creation.

Writer

Writer is both affordable and versatile, offering various content templates. Despite its low cost, the quality of the generated content was not impressive, with the writing often lacking depth. It scored 10 out of 20.

Writesonic

Writesonic stood out for its SEO-focused content generation. The tool performed well, producing coherent and relevant content, and scored 13 out of 20. Its reasonable pricing and comprehensive features made it a strong contender.

Anyword

Anyword's predictive performance analysis is a notable feature, offering valuable insights into content effectiveness. However, the tool was less intuitive for prompt-based writing, resulting in a score of 11 out of 20.

Ink Editor

Ink Editor is primarily focused on SEO content. However, it fell short in terms of general writing functionality, scoring the lowest at 7 out of 20.

AI Writer

AI Writer, while affordable, was limited by character input restrictions for prompts and often produced generic content. It scored 11 out of 20.

Claude 3 (Opus)

Claude 3 (Opus) was the clear winner, scoring 18 out of 20. The tool excelled in generating human-like, empathetic, and relevant content, making it a top choice for Rick. It offers excellent ease of use and is reasonably priced at $20 per month.


Conclusion

Rick Mulready's comprehensive evaluation highlights Claude 3 (Opus) as the leading AI writing tool, surpassing its competitors in generating high-quality, engaging content. Whether you're a business owner, content creator, or marketer, Claude 3 is a reliable tool to enhance your writing process.